Career Women (1) | 职场女性和女性管理者

They call it a career path, but most days it feels like a jungle gym where the prize for winning is just more work and a few more grey hairs.

CAREER

2/8/20263 min read

中文(English version follows below)

职场话题(1):职场女性和女性管理者

先谈一些大的教训 (道理浅显,但只有经历过的人才能真正明白 -多么痛的领悟呀)

1. 工作能力和努力上进在升入中层管理时还是被看中的,越往上走就越不被看中了。往上走被看中是因为人在他们的小圈子里,是他们的嫡系亲属, 或他们能培养出来的拥护者。所以一个不比你有经验,有成绩,和有好的合作能力的人,分分钟都能代替你,就用他们理所当然的理由,甚至都不要啥理由。当然还是可以认真工作的,我们要显现自己专业的一面,但不要老觉得 “I will prove it ONE more time so that they will recognize me.” No, they won’t!

2. 明白了上面这个道理,期望值就要放低,不要老患得患失的。你努力工作的目的是一要这份工资,二要尽量能心情愉快地工作。你累坏了累死了没有人会真正可怜你,你家人特别是孩子会最可怜。所以你得把心态放对了,看很多工作的问题不过就是在要走流程,按班就步就好。我曾经为了老板的业绩也为了自我表现,带着我的团队,累到我的月经紊乱得看医生,同时几个队员生病失眠。换上今天的我,我会继续干好活,但不会牺牲自己的健康去掏心掏肺了。 老板为了升官能逼人到这个份上,很多过后也不会记得你的好,只会给你更多活,反正你又一次证明了你真是太能干了嘛。

3.和你的直接老板搞好关系是最重要的,即使这个老板不懂技术(西方职场很多时候是管理和技术分开的,不奇怪),即使这个老板只是个芝麻官,即使你的大老板似乎更欣赏你。。。还是好好和直接老板搞好关系,如果实在是碰上了一个恶魔,还是离开吧,不值得把自己拖垮。和老板搞好关系不是一定要拍马屁,要职业化,要讲技巧 say no in a yes way, 见下一条。

4. 刚开始做管理者的女性,1)往往爱一下就意气风发,和老板承诺很多事情 (over promise deliverables and deadlines)。这时候应该和老板说,谢谢他/她和你谈目标 (马屁),你回去理一下拿出具体方案和你的团队商量一下(缓兵之策),再回来和老板请教如何排序prioritize(马屁请教)。把你想做能做的放前面说,不能做的就说团队有顾虑如时间紧人手不够技术不支持等,请老板决定做什么先而不是什么都一起做。即使最后还是都得拼命做,至少老板知道你在拼命了。2)大包大揽,和手下交流烦,不如自己做得快时干脆就自己做了。见下条。

5. 有的手下总丢三落四的,让他/她和你对话是记笔记,走前口头复述要点,下次带着同样的笔记本,来和你一一对接工作。有的手下是等着你的明确指令才会做活的,那就直接下指令定好交货期和质量。有的手下不配合还可能要和你对着干,那就多用e-mail 留下证据。如果对方有什么不专业的行为,一开始就要开个文件,记录下当时发生了什么有没有证人在场。同时要和你老板时不时的沟通,啥时下PIP,到时你们一块开这个人就水到渠成了。

总之,要学会分配任务,检查任务,支持任务,和结束任务。不同的手下性格不同,要用不同手段,即使再生气,表面也平静甚至是微笑的(这得练没办法)。哎,中层关人真是累,体验过的人都知道无官一身轻。

6. 找个有经验的能信得过的mentor,平时主动聚一聚聊天,不要等到有事才找人。不一定是高层女性,你以为他们不是经历过磨难了才会帮助别的女性吗?坏人是不分性别的。

7. 越忙越要organized 越要高效, 每天写To-do-list,不管大事小事,包括生活的事,然后一条一条地化掉,真的很有成就感,也大大减少焦虑。你一副无头苍蝇的忙样,没有人会认真地对待你,包括你的手下。

8.学习一下工作中说话的技巧,有很多关于人的心理学。比如你都气得要死了,与其说:We have talked about this several times. It won''''''''t work! ...可以“皮笑肉不笑”地说:I think we are 90% on the same page. I really like what you said about... (挑个能引申到你想做的)。I remember Catie suggested that WE add... (也是你想做的).That is great, too. We can scale it up if we can integrate her idea into yours. How about…(加入你想做的)?

这一招就是先表扬,再恭维对方往你要去的路上引导,然后多用问句提出你的想法,让对方只在你的框架里提建议时感觉良好。

人在感觉被尊重(feel respected),被融入( engaged), 和被参与(involved)的时候,比较容易听你的。这一招不一定每次都有用,但比我当年的直来直去效果好多了。这不是母语的问题,我的美国老板经常派我去处理一堆人事牵扯的难事情,就是因为他知道自己说话太直了。所以说话的艺术是可以学习的。

English Version


Career Insights (1): Navigating the Corporate World as a Woman and Manager

Here are some major lessons learned—simple in theory, but deeply painful to realize in practice:

1. The Ceiling of Meritocracy

Hard work and competence matter when rising to middle management. However, the higher you go, the less they matter. Promotion to the top is often about being in the "inner circle," being a loyalist, or being a protégé. Someone with less experience or fewer results can replace you in a heartbeat for their own reasons—or no reason at all. Keep your professionalism, but stop thinking: "I will prove it ONE more time so they finally recognize me." No, they won't.

2. Protect Your Health and Family

Once you lower your expectations, you stop obsessing over every win or loss. You work for two things: your paycheck and your mental well-being. If you work yourself to death, no one in the company will truly pity you—but your children and family will suffer the most. I once pushed myself and my team so hard to meet a boss’s goals that my health failed, and several team members suffered from insomnia. Today, I would still do a good job, but I would never sacrifice my health for a company that will likely forget my sacrifice and simply reward me with more work.

3. Manage Your Direct Boss Above All

Your relationship with your direct supervisor is paramount. Even if they aren't technical, even if they are low-ranking, and even if the "Big Boss" likes you more—prioritize your direct boss. If you find yourself working for a true "devil," leave. It’s not worth the toll on your life. "Managing up" isn't about flattery; it’s about professionalism and the art of saying "no" in a "yes" way.

4. Advice for New Female Managers

  • Don't Over-Promise: New managers often want to impress and promise too much. Instead, thank the boss for the goals, tell them you need to consult your team to create a concrete plan (a stalling tactic), and then return to ask the boss to help prioritize the tasks. Frame what you can do first, and highlight constraints (time, headcount) for the rest. Let the boss choose the priority so they understand the effort required.

  • Avoid "Doing it All Yourself": Don't take over tasks just because it's faster than explaining it to a subordinate. You must delegate to survive.

5. Handling Different Types of Subordinates

  • The Forgetful: Have them take notes, repeat key points before leaving, and bring the same notebook to every follow-up.

  • The Order-Taker: Give clear, direct instructions with firm deadlines.

  • The Difficult/Non-compliant: Document everything via email. If they are unprofessional, start a "paper trail" immediately (dates, incidents, witnesses). Communicate with your boss regularly so that if a PIP (Performance Improvement Plan) becomes necessary, the transition is seamless.

  • The Poker Face: Learn to remain calm or even smile while managing people, even when you're fuming inside. Middle management is exhausting; there is a unique freedom in "returning to the ranks."

6. Find a Mentor Early

Find an experienced, trustworthy mentor and maintain that relationship through regular chats—don't just reach out when there’s a crisis. And remember: "bad actors" have no gender. Don't assume every senior woman will help you just because she's a woman; some had to become hardened to get where they are.

7. Stay Organized to Stay Sane

The busier you are, the more organized you must be. Write a daily To-Do list (including life errands). Crossing items off reduces anxiety and gives a sense of achievement. If you act like a "headless chicken," no one—including your subordinates—will take you seriously.

8. The Art of "Corporate Speak"

Instead of letting your anger show and saying, "We've talked about this, it won't work!" try a more psychological approach. Use a "smiling" tone:

"I think we are 90% on the same page. I really like what you said about [X]. I also remember Catie suggested we add [Y]—that’s a great idea too. We can scale this up if we integrate her idea with yours. How about we... [insert what you actually want to do]?"

This method involves praising first, guiding the other person toward your goal, and using questions to make them feel like they are contributing within your framework. People are much more cooperative when they feel respected, engaged, and involved. This isn't a language issue; it’s a psychological one. Even native speakers use these "soft skills" to navigate hard situations.